Thanks for visiting the Art of the Image blog. We've moved over to www.artoftheimage.com so this blog is no longer updated, but please feel free to peruse the articles and content here.

When you're finished, please visit us at www.artoftheimage.com for all the current blog posts and information. Thanks!!!
Showing posts with label Canon DPP. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Canon DPP. Show all posts

Friday, September 25, 2009

Developing Canon G10 RAW - Lightroom vs Canon DPP

I was fooling around with some photos I took with my Canon G10 at the Cambridge Fair, and I thought I'd run them through Canon DPP in addition to Lightroom, which I usually use for all my RAW developing.

As regular readers know, I'm a Lightroom lover, but I was just curious to see how the two sets of photos looked in comparison to each other. I didn't do any editing or adjustments. These are as shot.

Click on any of the photos to see a larger image.


Lightroom


Canon DPP

Pretty hard to see any difference here. Both look good, which is also a testament to the venerable little Canon G10 and P mode. Yes, I've been shooting the G10 in P mode a lot lately. It just works!


Lightroom


Canon DPP

This one I actually prefer the color rendering a little better on the Lightroom image, but again, it's so close, it's almost hard to tell them apart.


Lightroom


Canon DPP

Going to give the nod to the Canon DPP image on this one, mostly for shadow and mid tones. Again though, I'm splitting hairs. Both the Lightroom and the DPP images are very good and virtually identical.


Lightroom


Canon DPP


Lightroom


Canon DPP

Lightroom
Lightroom

Canon DPP
Canon DPP

I think I like the Lightroom version of this one a little better for it's slightly warmer colors.


Lightroom


Canon DPP

I think this one goes to Canon DPP by a slight margin as I like the blue rendering a little better than Lightroom's, but again, splitting hairs here.


Lightroom


Canon DPP

Hard to call on this one. You decide. :-)


Lightroom


Canon DPP


Lightroom


Canon DPP

Slight edge to DPP on this one for color, but again, it's so close.

Overall, most of these are really virtually identical. There are subtle differences, but not enough to be identifiable by most people. All the images from both Canon DPP and Lightroom are excellent. I would have no problem using either to develop my Canon G10 RAW files from an image quality standpoint.

That said, the big difference again is that Lightroom is a much faster, much more powerful tool. I wouldn't think twice about it. I'd just use Lightroom and be done with it.

Of course, if you don't own Lightroom and aren't interested in purchasing it, well then this also proves that you won't be losing anything by way of image quality using Canon DPP, even if your workflow takes you a wee bit longer.

I should also mention that at this point, Lightroom has become so much more than just a RAW developer for me. I rarely take my images into Photoshop anymore. Lightroom has so many great tools that I use regularly (i.e. the clone tool, grad filters, vignetting), that I don't need Photoshop for the bulk of my images.

This is a major difference between Canon DPP and Lightroom. You don't get these kind of tools in DPP, so I'd be doing additional work in Photoshop if I was using DPP to develop my RAW files. With Lightroom, it's a one step solution! Not only is Lightroom faster, you can do so much more to finish your images than you can in DPP.

More on the Canon G10...

Shooting the G10 at ISO 800 and ISO 1600

Closeup Pics Using Macro Mode On the Canon G10

Mrs. Ballard Shoots The Canon G10 - Straight Out Of Camera Jpegs

Shooting the Canon G10 With An SB-26 Off Camera Flash

Canon G10 Unboxing & Why I Bought A Canon G10

5 Reasons To Sell Your Canon G10 And Buy A G11

Thursday, July 16, 2009

Canon DPP Workflow

I've had quite a few requests for my Canon DPP workflow, so here it is!

I've also made it available as a short eBook pdf which you can download for FREE.



Matt Ballard's Canon DPP Workflow

Import images by plugging your memory card into the computer. I use a Sandisk SDR-88 USB card reader. This is the current version.



Open windows explorer and find the your memory card in the directory tree.



Drag and drop the DCIM folder with your photos in it from the memory card to a location on your computer. I drag them to a folder named “Photos” on my data drive, so that's F:\Photos for me.

Once the DCIM folder is finished copying to your hard drive, check that all the files have copied correctly. Check the number of files is the same on both the memory card and in the new folder.

Rename the new folder to whatever you like by right-clicking the folder and clicking Rename from the drop-down menu. I use a date and description (i.e. “2009july11 Lilly”).

Open DPP. Make sure you're on the folder tab in the top left and find your new image folder in the directory tree.



Once you've found your new image folder, click on it and your images will appear as thumbnails in the main window.

Press the alt + a keys to select all the images, then the alt + q keys to open the quick check tool. If the quick check tool window doesn't open full screen, I drag the edges out so that the image fills my screen.

Use the left and right arrow keys to scroll through the images, keeping the cursor hovering over the 1 button. Assign a 1 to your keepers by clicking the 1 key as you scroll through. This can be done one handed or two handed, whichever you prefer, but it is very quick once you get the hang of it. I don't bother with the 2 and 3 ratings. I just put a 1 on anything that's a keeper.

Remember, while using the quick check tool you can double click anywhere on the image to zoom in.

When you're finished going through all the images and assigning a 1 to your keepers, go to the View drop down menu, click Sort, and click CheckMark1 from the drop down menu. Now all your keepers will be resorted to the top of the thumbnails in the main window

Press ctrl + alt + 1 to select all the keepers, then click the Edit Image Window icon in the top left corner of DPP.

The Edit Image Window should open with all a thumbnail strip of all your keepers along the left side of the first image.



NOTE: if you're editing an event like a wedding where you have hundreds or thousands of images, only select 25 to 50 images so that you're working on them in smaller batches at a time instead of using ctrl alt 1 to select all your keepers as DPP doesn't like to work on too many images at once. Alternately, select small groups of up to 50 images that are similar that you will want to copy and paste the same adjustments to.

Make your image adjustments to the first image using the editing controls on the right.

Now you can either move through each file making quick adjustments if your images differ from each other enough that you don't want to copy and paste adjustments, OR...

right click on the image and click copy recipe to clipboard from the pull down menu. Then click the main window icon in the top left to go back to the main window with all your thumbnails, select all the images that are similar to the one you just edited, right click and click Paste Recipe To Selected Image from the pull down menu.

Select your next image in a series, and repeat.

Once you have all the images edited, press ctrl + alt + 1 from the main window to select all your edited keepers, then click the batch process window, input your desired settings and click execute.

With my computer (quad core with 6GB of RAM) I can usually batch all my images, even a thousand or two with no trouble. If your computer has trouble doing this, try smaller batches at a time. Your computer may be able to handle running several smaller batches consecutively or you may have to run them seperately.

For more detailed information on what each of the settings and adjustments do in Canon DPP, Canon's DPP Manual is very good. Here's the link to Canon's Download Library.

Canon's DPP Online Tutorials are very good too. Here's the link.



Other Recommended Reading:

How To Thrive As An Artist Without Selling Out:
The Unconventional Guide to Art and Money

Tuesday, July 7, 2009

Lightroom vs Canon DPP

Since I posted my Lightroom vs Nikon Capture / Nikon View article, I've had quite a few inquiries about my thoughts on Lightroom vs Canon's DPP (Digital Photo Professional) software.

I always liked DPP when I worked with it. It was very easy to work with (once you got the workflow figured out) and capable of delivering excellent quality RAW develops from Canon CR2 files. (for those that missed it, here's the link to my previous article on using Canon DPP.)

So I got to thinking that an actual comparison between Lightroom and DPP was in order.

Overall, my thoughts on comparing the RAW develops from each are very similar to the Lightroom vs Nikon comparison I did. In general, DPP does a better job right out of the gate with no tinkering.

You can get the same results, or very close, from Lightroom, but DPP provides a beautiful result right out of the camera as it were.

Between DPP and Lightroom, sometimes I liked the DPP file slightly better, and sometimes I liked the Lightroom file a little better. I used the Camera Standard profile in Lightroom, so the results were always pretty close (once I turned off my own presets).

That's the big thing that's changed since I used DPP a lot. Lightroom introduced camera profiles, and they do an excellent job of giving you the same or similar results as you would have got with a straight out of camera jpg or with the Canon software.

My conclusion here would be that DPP is great for quick and easy RAW to jpg conversions without having to tinker. Lightroom can take some tinkering to get an equally good result, but it's much better now that we have the camera profiles available.

Lightroom can match or come VERY close to Canon's DPP in quality when it comes to developing RAW CR2 Canon files. When it comes to workflow, speed, and versatility, Lightroom just blows Canon DPP away, although not as bad as it does Nikon. DPP is much more usable than the Nikon software.

Let's look at a couple images to see the results.

These are all from RAW files, developed as is with no adjustments (except a small exposure correction in a couple of them).

Lightroom 2 develops were set to Camera Standard as that was my default camera setting with my Canon DSLR's. DPP already defaults to the camera setting and does not need to be set in the software.

All the images have been saved at 800 pixels on the long side. The images aren't posted for pixel-peeping, only to show the basic differences between the Lightroom and DPP RAW develops. Please don't email with complaints about pure testing methods and such... that's not why I posted these.



Here's my bulldog Hyla, posing for the camera (Canon 30D) with a pair of sunglasses on. In this instance, DPP rendered the contrast and tones a little punchier than Lightroom did.

I actually like the DPP shot better, but I can get the same thing out of Lightroom very easily. For a quick and easy develop with no tinkering, I have to say DPP beat Lightroom here.



Here's a shot of a bride from a wedding I shot with a Canon 20D. Both are very similar, but I have to give the edge to the DPP develop.

Again, I could've got the same look in Lightroom very quickly, but DPP rendered this beautifully with no tinkering.



This bridal party shot (Canon Rebel XTi) is so close I almost wouldn't call a winner.

On close inspection in Photoshop, I'm going to give a slight nod to DPP, but it's so close it's probably more appropriate to call it a draw. Lightroom does an excellent job here.



This shot (Canon Rebel XTi) of a bride and groom with a train in the background is a tie. I can't even tell the difference in Photoshop without really studying it. Even then, neither is better than the other. Lightroom matches DPP quality here.



This photo of the Lake Erie shoreline in winter (Canon 30D) is, again, very close. I actually think Lightroom won this one by a slight margin, because I prefer the detail rendering Lightroom did, especially in the log on the shore.

Again though, they're so close it's hard to call a winner. Lightroom does a great job with color and kudos for the better detail rendering.

It's worth noting that DPP doesn't demand as much from your computer as Lightroom does. Lightroom likes as much power as you can give it, while DPP runs quite comfortably on a less than top of the line machine.

DPP is a valid alternative to Lightroom if you don't want to spend the money on Lightroom. Workflow isn't as good or as fast as Lightroom's, but it's still very usable. I used to use DPP as my primary RAW conversion software for a year or more.

If you're a Lightroom convert like myself, consider using DPP when you're having trouble getting an image just right in Lightroom. You may be surprised how good it looks in DPP without having to make any adjustments at all.

Feel free to post a comment and let me know your experiences with DPP.

If you don't have Adobe Photoshop Lightroom 2, Amazon usually has the best price.




See you behind the camera!

Matt

Canon DPP Workflow & FREE E-book

How to Thrive as an Artist Without Selling Out:
The Unconventional Guide to Art and Money

Monday, August 27, 2007

Canon DPP - Digital Photo Professional for RAW & JPG

I'm sure a lot of folks haven't even tried, or considered trying, Canon's DPP (Digital Photo Professional) software that comes bundled with Canon DSLR's. I know I didn't until a photographer friend I respect a lot told me that's what he is using to process most of his Canon CR2 RAW files.

So I decided to check it out, and I quickly decided it wasn't for me. Like most things in life, change isn't usually welcome. We get set in our ways and used to the way we do things. DPP seemed slow, and the interface didn't appeal to me.

Almost a year later, another conversation with my same friend had me deciding to try DPP again. This time I decided to give it a more thorough testing, and actually process an entire wedding with it. My initial reaction was similar to the first time I tried it... I didn't care for it. BUT, I forced myself to experiment some more and give it a fair shot. Boy am I glad I did!

What I soon found was that DPP is the fastest way to get the best looking results from my Canon files. Whether from my 20D, 30D, 40D, or XTi, DPP wins every time for image quality. I tested it again and again against other RAW processors including ACR, Bibble, and Capture One. DPP kept producing the best image files with the best color.

Skin tones are awesome with DPP... better than anything I've been able to get using any other RAW converter. And the workflow is actually very fast once you get your head wrapped around it. Now that I've gotten used to using DPP and developed my own workflow with it, I can fly through a wedding of 1,000 to 2,000 images faster with DPP than I could with ACR, Lightroom, Bibble, or Capture One.

AND I GET THE BEST COLORS, SKIN TONES, AND FILE QUALITY!

This is the biggie folks. DPP is giving me the best quality images I've yet to see from Canon files, and once I forced myself to give it a fair chance, my workflow is faster than ever using DPP.

Another plus using DPP is that you can get the same look from a CR2 RAW file as you would've got shooting in-camera jpgs. How many times have you fiddled and fiddled with a RAW image trying to get it to look like it would've had it been an in-camera jpg? I know I have many, many times. Not now.

DPP recognizes your in-camera settings when it loads the CR2 RAW files and will give you the same jpg as you would've got shooting jpg with your camera. This alone is awesome! No need to shoot RAW + Jpg anymore! Just shoot RAW and let DPP do your conversions, without any adjustment if you want it to look as you shot it in-camera, or with adjustments if you want to make corrections.

The other BIG thing I've just recently noticed with DPP, is that it gives you a degree of highlight recovery for jpgs, not just RAW CR2 files. As you know, jpgs hold up pretty well to basic adjustment and exposure increases, BUT they don't offer any degree of high-light recovery. That's a big reason why most of us professional photographers shoot RAW. We're not always perfect, and it's nice to have some high-light recovery latitude if you've made a boo-boo.

Until now that is... DPP will give you some high-light recovery with jpgs. From my experiences, it's not nearly as significant as the degree of high-light recovery you'll get from a CR2 RAW file, but it does give you some, which is better than none.

Try it for yourself. Shoot some jpg images with varying degrees of over-exposure. Open them up in DPP and see how much high-light recovery you can get. I think you'll be pleasantly surprised.

While I'm on the subject of high-light recovery, I should mention that it is the one area where DPP does not beat the rest. Adobe's Lightroom, from my observations, is currently the best at high-light recovery from RAW files. DPP is good, just not as good as Lightroom. I'd say DPP will give you a full stop to 1 1/2 stops of highlight recovery, depending on the image, whereas Lightroom will usually give you 1 1/2 to 2 stops, depending on the image.

So, if you aren't using DPP, give it a try. If you've tried it before, and decided against it as I had, try it again. Give it a good chance. You may just change your RAW workflow for the better. :-)

Best of all... it's free!

(Update: Read my latest article on Lightroom vs Canon DPP here.)